An analysis of the causes and process of the Islamic Revolution based on the natural history theories of revolutions

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Department of Political Science, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences, Ardakan University, Ardakan, Iran

Abstract

Why and how revolutions take place is one of the important issues that have been considered by philosophers, historians and political thinkers for centuries, and the result of their theoretical efforts has been the formation of various theories about the revolution. Jack Goldstone has explored these theories in three different generations (natural history theories, general theories of political violence, and structural theories). The main purpose of this study is an analysis of the process of the Islamic Revolution based on the views of the first generation of theorists of revolutions entitled "natural history theories". The research method in this study is descriptive-analytical and the data collection tool is library and Internet resources. The results show that in some cases, the causes of the Islamic Revolution, such as changing the allegiance of intellectuals, late and failed reforms of the Pahlavi regime, the fall of the Pahlavi regime with an acute political crisis, differences between revolutionaries and the temporary rise to power of moderates to some extent. The first generation is the natural history theories of revolutions. In general, it can be said that although the phenomenon of the Islamic Revolution in some of the above cases is somewhat in line with the views of the first generation of theorists of the revolution, but it is not fully compatible with the views of these theorists.

Keywords


  1. Abrahamian, Yervand (2011). History of modern Iran, translated by Mohammad Ebrahim Fatahi, Tehran: Ni
  2. Kazemi brothers, Massoud; Shokrane Araznaghi, Omid (2018). A comparative study and comparison of the Iranian revolution and the French revolution based on the theory of Crane Brinton, Political Strategy Quarterly, 3 (10): 183-203.
  3. Brinton, Crane (2019). An Autopsy of the Four Revolutions, translated by Mohsen Talasi, Tehran: Tamdan Elmi
  4. Hatami, Mohammadreza; Bigi, Alireza (2017). A comparative analysis of Iran's Islamic revolution with Bahrain's February 14 movement based on Goldstone's fourth generation theory. Islamic Revolution Research Journal, 8(28): 135-153.
  5. Zibakalam, Sadegh (2010). An introduction to the Islamic Revolution, Tehran: Rozeneh
  6. Shabannia, Qasim (2011). Evaluation of the revolution rotation theory and its application to the Iranian Islamic Revolution. Political Knowledge, 4(2): 123-140.
  7. Enayat Mehri, Mohammad Reza (2018). A comparative study of Crane Brinton's theory about revolutions with the causes of the Islamic revolution in Iran, Master's thesis, Mazandaran University, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences
  8. Ayouzi, Mohammad Rahim (2006). Abolition or change in theories of revolution, Zamaneh magazine, (-) 65.
  9. Foran, John (2014). Fragile Resistance: The History of Iran's Social Developments from the Safavid Period to the Years After the Islamic Revolution, translated by Ahmad Tedin, Tehran: Rasa Cultural Services Institute
  10. Faizi, Fazel; Rahmani, Maryam (1391). Reasons for the downfall of the provisional government of the merchant engineer based on the theory of Crane Brinton. Journal of Political and International Studies, 3(10), 37-59.
  11. Ghasemi Behzad, Bakhtiari Mohammad (2019). A comparative study of Jack Goldstone's theory with Iran's Islamic Revolution and Yemen's political developments. Scientific-Research Quarterly of Islamic Revolution Studies. 17 (60): 201-222.
  12. Cohen, Alvin Stanford (2019). Revolution theories, translated by Alireza Tayyeb, Tehran: Qoms
  13. Goldstone, Jack (2012). Theoretical, comparative and historical studies on revolutions, translated by Mohammad Taghi Delfrooz, Tehran: Kovir
  14. Mohammadi Iraqi, Mohammad Shahabuddin (1383). Investigating the causes of the failure of liberal-Islamic elites to maintain power after the revolution, Master's thesis, Faculty of Law and Political Sciences, University of Tehran.
  15. Mohammadi, Manouchehr (2012). The Islamic Revolution: Contexts and Consequences, Qom: Supreme Leader's Representation Institution in Universities, Maarif Publishing House.
  16. Malkutian, Mustafa (1384). Siri in the theories of revolution, Tehran: Qoms
  17. Manouchehri, Abbas (2012). Revolution theories, Tehran: Samt
  18. Herati, Mohammad Javad; Soltani Moghadam, Saeeda (2019). Testability of Jack Goldstone's revolution theory with revolutions in Tunisia, Egypt. International Relations Research, 10(1): 201-228.
  19. Coccia, M. (2019). Theories of Revolution. Global Encyclopedia of Public Administration, Public Policy, and Governance, 1-7.
  20. Arendt, H (1963). On revolution. Viking, New York
  21. Deutsch, K. W. (1964). External involvement in internal war in Eckstein, H., & Eckstein, H. Internal war: problems and approaches. Free Press of Glencoe. pp. 100–110.
  22. De Tocqueville, A (1955). The old regime and the French revolution. Doubleday, New York
  23. Davies, J. C. (1962). Towards a theory of revolution. American sociological review, 5-19.